Twitter Facebook Vimeo

Create a flawless portfolio that everyone loves

1 min, 28 sec read
8:29 AM | 14 October 2013
by Jim Compton-hall
   •       •   
Become an FR Writer

Struggling with too many contradictory comments about your portfolio? Here's what to do.

Sorry, that heading might be a tad misleading in that you can't. It's impossible. And trying to please everyone will be your downfall.

Advertising/design/etc are all unbelievably subjective and different people like to see different things.

These are just some of the things I've been told at book crits:

  • Stop showing me advertising.  I want to see a bunch of random projects and quirky creative stuff that you enjoy doing so I can see how you mind works.
  • Anything that isn't advertising, get rid off. I don't want to see it.
  • We want to see crazy stuff like weird contrasting tones of voice. What if you were to use swear words in a lollipop ad?
  • This is bad because it is not how this brand would advertise.
  • Campaign A is the best thing in your book, but campaign B needs more work.
  • Campaign A isn't very good but I love campaign B.
  • This is nice. You should mock it up.
  • You shouldn't be showing me any mocked up stuff. Just scamps.

So how do you produce a book that will get you a job?

More stories

  1. Publishing your first book with an unsolicited manuscript

    Want to publish your book but you don't have a solicited manuscript? We have listed the publishing houses that accept unsolicited manuscripts, organised by genre.

  2. How to be seen

    Graphic designer, Christine Johnson, shows us a different perspective to self-promotion with a pair of eye-catching wooden sunglasses she designed.

  3. Students response to gender inequality in Europe

    AdVenture is a competition in response to a brief for the European Women's Lobby and gender equality. Team Tortoise from Leeds College of Arts (UK) won the competition in 2017 with their campaign, 'What are you laughing at?'.

  4. Everything you need to know about studying creative digital arts

    Creative digital arts student, Rachael Rampat, delves into what to expect from studying the course.

  5. 5 red flags you’re burning out at work

    Work is a huge part of our lives, but you can’t let it take over. Look out for these five red flags and how to avoid and fix them.

  6. Creative developer’s cubic portfolio

    Alex Motzenbecker, a Creative Developer from New York neatly promotes his collection of work and skills.

×